Rethinking Who Shaped the American Revolution

Oct. 30, 2026

Author: Naya Hall

The American Revolution is often remembered as a fight for freedom, but whose freedom did it secure? Historian Kathleen DuVal’s lecture explored how Native nations shaped the Revolution through their own political decisions and alliances, even as the war’s outcome threatened the lands and sovereignty they fought to protect.

kathleen duval speaking at the podium

On October 6, 2026, Kathleen DuVal, Ph.D., (University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill), presented a talk entitled "Native Nations and the American Revolution" at the Virginia Museum of History and Culture as part of the annual Society of the Cincinnati lecture series. In introducing the lecture, VCU professor Carolyn Eastman, Ph.D., explained that the event was “the seventeenth annual lecture in the series, which brings scholars to discuss the political, military, and economic history of the American Revolution." 

DuVal began by stating, “Native Americans' history is often left out.” This idea became the central point of the lecture, challenging the familiar story of the Revolution as just a fight between the British and the colonists. 

Her discussion of how Native nations fought to protect their land demonstrated the depth and complexity of their struggles. In 1758, the British promised to respect Native hunting grounds through the Treaty of Easton. After winning the Seven Years' War, however, the British began moving settlers onto Native land, breaking the promise. This contributed to the further conflicts, including Pontiac’s War in 1763. These events help explain why Native nations viewed the British government as a potential barrier against colonial expansion. Their own political goals shaped their role in the American Revolution, not just loyalty to one side. DuVal emphasized this independence when she stated that Native nations “will make decisions as sovereign nations, which they are.” Native nations were not just reacting to decisions made by European powers; they had their own governments, relationships, and priorities, and they made choices they believed would protect their communities.

A discussion of the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Confederacy added further complexity to the topic. As DuVal explained, the Confederacy’s six nations didn’t all support the same side during the Revolution. Mohawks and Senecas generally sided with the British, while the Oneidas and Tuscaroras had stronger ties to the American colonists and served with the patriot. In August 1777, members of the Confederacy found themselves fighting against one another. Afterwards, they chose to not risk fighting against their fellow Haudenosaunee again. The Native nations that sided with the British government shifted their support efforts towards attacking settlements instead of fighting in major battles. This decision showed that Native nations made choices to protect their own communities and interpersonal relationships: "they make their own foreign policies,” DuVal stated. This reinforces her main point that Native nations were independent political communities, not just side characters in someone else's story. 

By exploring what happened to Native nations after the American colonies won their independence, DuVal showed that with the Treaty of Paris that ended the war, Britain gave the new United States claims over Native lands without consent of Native peoples. Native nations that supported the American colonists, like the Oneidas and Catawba, also lost land. These outcomes complicate the popular narrative of American independence as a win against tyranny. While the Revolution created a new independent country, Native nations continued to see their land and freedoms stolen. Their experiences reveal the limitations of telling the story of the Revolution only through the lens of one perspective. 

After the lecture, attendees shared what stood out to them. Maya, a second-year VCU political science student, said, “I learned a lot more about Native Nations than I ever have before.” Her favorite part was learning about the treaties between the British and the Haudenosaunee Confederacy during the Seven Years’ War. 

Tyler Robertson, a graduate student studying history at VCU, praised the lecture as “very wonderful and insightful," highlighting how much he learned about the Haudenosaunee. 

Sarah Meacham, Ph.D., a professor and colonial American historian at VCU, was impressed by DuVal’s use of empirical evidence and global perspective. She praised DuVal’s work and highlighted her ability to incorporate different nations into the lecture.
 
DuVal’s lecture highlighted the vital part Native nations played in shaping the American Revolution. By centering Native sovereignty and experiences, the lecture challenged the popular narrative of the Revolution and showed why a fuller understanding of American independence must include the nations whose histories are often left out.